San Mar has a pretty good Tall that sounds exactly what you want and have killer shipping and service! They are only 2+ on the length and not the sleeves I think. They are what I am using but I'm not sure how happy I am with them because of a couple reasons. They DON'T have tall in M (nor does anybody) and is my main reason for needing "talls", price is ok for the quality (around $3.00) but they are VERY "fuzzy" shirts out of the box and kinda a pain if your screen printing them. The blacks do fade pretty bad and fairly quick.
I don't like bashing but I wouldn't recommended the S.A.A.D line from
Wholesale Blank T Shirts Online WDUSA as many people on here will. If you do do order from here order the min and you will see what I'm talkin about. I can elaborate if needed.